The $200K Question: Building vs. Buying Technology Leadership for Mid-Market Manufacturers

The Conversation Every Growing Manufacturer Has

“We need better technology leadership.”

That realization typically hits mid-market manufacturers somewhere between $30M and $100M in revenue. You’ve outgrown the “IT person who also handles technology strategy” model, but you haven’t reached enterprise scale where a full leadership team is obviously justified.

You’re stuck in the middle—facing enterprise-level technology challenges without enterprise budgets.

Last week, we had this exact conversation with three different manufacturers. Same revenue range ($45M-$75M). Same technology challenges (aging systems, security concerns, digital transformation pressure). Same question:

“What’s the most cost-effective way to get the technology leadership we need?”

The answer isn’t what most expect.

The True Cost of Full-Time Technology Leadership

Let’s start with real numbers. Here’s what a full-time technology leadership team actually costs for a mid-market manufacturer:

Option 1: Full-Time CIO

Direct costs:

• Base salary: $180,000 - $250,000 (depending on geography and experience)
• Benefits (health, 401k, etc.): $54,000 - $75,000 (30% of base)
• Payroll taxes: $18,000 - $25,000
• Annual compensation: $252,000 - $350,000

Hidden costs:

• Recruiting fees: $40,000 - $60,000 (20-25% of salary)
• Onboarding and ramp time: 3-6 months at reduced productivity
• Office, equipment, travel: $15,000 - $25,000 annually
• Professional development: $8,000 - $15,000 annually
• First-year total: $315,000 - $450,000

Ongoing annual cost: $275,000 - $390,000

Option 2: Full-Time CIO + CISO

Many manufacturers need both strategic technology leadership AND security expertise (especially with CMMC, cyber insurance requirements, and increasing threats).

Annual costs:

• CIO: $275,000 - $390,000
• CISO: $240,000 - $360,000 (CISO often costs more than CIO due to shortage)
• Combined annual: $515,000 - $750,000

This is obviously out of reach for most mid-market manufacturers.

Option 3: Senior IT Manager (Instead of CIO)

Some manufacturers try to bridge the gap with a senior IT manager who handles both operations and strategy.

Annual costs:

• Base salary: $120,000 - $160,000
• Benefits and taxes: $40,000 - $55,000
• Total: $160,000 - $215,000

The problem: This rarely works. The skills for managing day-to-day IT operations are fundamentally different from strategic technology leadership. You end up with someone who’s:

• Overwhelmed trying to do both tactical and strategic work
• Focused on firefighting instead of planning
• Lacking the enterprise experience to guide major initiatives
• Unable to credibly engage with C-suite and board on technology strategy

We see this pattern constantly: manufacturers spend $180K annually on a senior IT manager and still don’t have the strategic leadership they need.

The Hidden Costs Nobody Talks About

The salary comparison is just the beginning. Here are the hidden costs of full-time technology leadership:

1. The Specialization Problem

Technology leadership isn’t one job anymore—it’s multiple specializations:

Strategic technology leadership (CIO):

• Technology strategy and roadmap
• Digital transformation
• ERP and major system selection
• Vendor management and negotiations
• IT budget and investment planning

Cybersecurity leadership (CISO):

• Security architecture and strategy
• Compliance (CMMC, NIST, ISO, etc.)
• Risk management and cyber insurance
• Incident response planning
• Security vendor management

AI and data strategy (CAIO):

• AI/ML opportunity assessment
• Data architecture and governance
• Analytics and business intelligence
• AI vendor evaluation and implementation
• Data-driven decision-making culture

The reality: One person can’t be world-class at all three. But hiring three executives costs $700K-$1.1M annually—impossible for mid-market.

2. The Geography Problem

Let’s say you’re a manufacturer in:

• Rural Pennsylvania
• Upstate New York
• Wisconsin
• The Carolinas (outside major metros)

Challenge: The experienced CIO willing to relocate to your location and work for mid-market compensation is… rare.

Your choices:

• Pay 20-30% above market to attract someone to your location
• Hire someone less experienced and hope they grow into the role (risky for critical position)
• Accept 100% remote CIO (which creates different challenges)
• Relocate your technology leadership (expensive and often rejected by candidates)

3. The Utilization Problem

Here’s an uncomfortable truth: A mid-market manufacturer doesn’t need a full-time CIO’s time.

Breaking down how a CIO actually spends time in a mid-market manufacturer:

Strategic work (high value, CIO-level required):

• Technology strategy and planning: 15-20 hours/month
• Major project oversight (ERP, MES, digital transformation): 20-30 hours/month
• Vendor negotiations and management: 10-15 hours/month
• Board and executive engagement: 5-10 hours/month
• Total strategic work: 50-75 hours/month

Operational work (necessary but doesn’t require CIO-level expertise):

• Team management and 1-on-1s: 20-30 hours/month
• Operational meetings and status updates: 15-20 hours/month
• Budget tracking and reporting: 10-15 hours/month
• Vendor calls and administrative tasks: 15-25 hours/month
• Total operational work: 60-90 hours/month

The math: You’re paying $275K-$390K for someone spending 40-50% of their time on work that doesn’t require their level of expertise.

4. The Stagnation Risk

A concern we hear from manufacturers who’ve had full-time CIOs:

“Our CIO was great for the first 3 years. They modernized our infrastructure, implemented our ERP, built the team. But now, 5 years in, their approach feels stale. They’re comfortable but not pushing us forward.”

The challenge:

• Full-time executive in a mid-market environment can become isolated from innovation
• Limited peer interaction and external exposure
• Comfort with status quo instead of continuous improvement
• Difficulty justifying conference attendance, training, peer groups ($15K-$30K annually)

Fractional executives, by contrast, must stay current or they lose clients. They’re constantly exposed to new problems, technologies, and approaches across multiple companies.

The Fractional Leadership Model: A Different Economics

Here’s the alternative many mid-market manufacturers don’t fully understand:

Fractional CIO Model

Structure:

• Experienced CIO (typically 15-25 years enterprise experience)
• Engaged 1-3 days per week or monthly retainer hours
• Focused exclusively on strategic work
• Your existing IT team (or outsourced MSP) handles operations

Costs:

• Monthly retainer: $8,000 - $15,000 (depending on scope and engagement level)
• Annual cost: $96,000 - $180,000
• No benefits, recruiting fees, or overhead
• Immediate start (no 3-6 month search and onboarding)

What you get:

• Enterprise-level strategic technology leadership
• 50-75 hours monthly of focused strategic work (not diluted with operations)
• External perspective from someone working with multiple companies
• Flexibility to scale engagement up or down based on needs
• Access to broader network and expertise

Fractional CIO + CISO Model

For manufacturers needing both technology and security leadership:

Costs:

• Fractional CIO: $96,000 - $180,000 annually
• Fractional CISO: $96,000 - $180,000 annually
• Combined: $192,000 - $360,000 annually

Compare to full-time: $515,000 - $750,000 annually

Savings: 50-65% while getting specialized expertise in both areas

The “Fractional + Internal” Hybrid

The model that works best for many manufacturers:

Structure:

• Fractional CIO for strategy and leadership
• Internal IT Manager for operations ($120K-$160K)
• Fractional CISO for security (if needed)

Annual cost:

• Fractional CIO: $120,000 - $180,000
• IT Manager: $160,000 - $215,000
• Fractional CISO (optional): $96,000 - $144,000
• Total: $280,000 - $539,000

What you get:

• Day-to-day operational coverage (internal IT Manager)
• Strategic technology leadership (fractional CIO)
• Security expertise (fractional CISO)
• Clear separation of strategic vs. tactical work
• Coverage and continuity (multiple people, no single point of failure)

Compare to:

• Full-time CIO only: $275,000 - $390,000 (less total capability)
• Full-time CIO + CISO: $515,000 - $750,000 (higher cost, harder to recruit)

The Break-Even Analysis

When does full-time make sense vs. fractional?

We’ve analyzed dozens of manufacturers and found consistent patterns:

Fractional Makes Sense When:

Revenue: $20M - $120M

• Need strategic technology leadership
• Can’t justify $350K+ for full-time CIO
• Have or can hire internal IT operations staff
• Want flexibility to scale engagement
• Value external perspective and broad experience

Engagement sweet spot:

• 1-2 days per week for $50M-$75M manufacturers
• 2-3 days per week for $75M-$120M manufacturers
• Project-based for specific initiatives (ERP, digital transformation, CMMC)

Full-Time Makes Sense When:

Revenue: $150M+

• Multiple facilities requiring coordination
• Constant major technology initiatives
• Large internal IT team (10+ people) needing full-time leadership
• Complex custom systems requiring dedicated oversight
• Board expectation of full-time C-suite technology presence

Reality check: Even at $150M+, many manufacturers are choosing fractional for specialized roles (CISO, CAIO) while hiring full-time CIO.

Real-World ROI Comparison

Let’s compare the actual financial impact using a real scenario:

$60M manufacturer needs:

• ERP modernization
• CMMC Level 2 compliance
• Cybersecurity improvements
• IT cost optimization

Scenario 1: Full-Time CIO

Costs (Year 1):

• CIO recruiting and hiring: 3-4 months, $50K fees
• CIO compensation: $285,000
• Security consultant for CMMC: $120,000 (CIO isn’t CMMC expert)
• Total: $455,000

Results:

• CIO ramps up over 6 months
• ERP project starts month 7
• CMMC assessment begins month 8
• Some IT cost optimization
• Value delivered year 1: Moderate

Scenario 2: Fractional CIO + Fractional CISO

Costs (Year 1):

• Fractional CIO: $144,000 (2 days/week)
• Fractional CISO: $120,000 (focused on CMMC)
• Total: $264,000

Results:

• Immediate engagement (no search/onboarding delay)
• ERP project starts month 1 (fractional CIO has done 20+ ERP selections)
• CMMC program running month 1 (fractional CISO specializes in CMMC)
• IT cost optimization begins immediately
• Value delivered year 1: High

Year 1 cost savings: $191,000

Additional value:

• 6-month faster project start (fractional starts immediately vs. hire + ramp)
• Specialized CMMC expertise (vs. generalist CIO learning CMMC)
• IT cost optimization: $80K-$150K annually (experienced fractional CIO finds inefficiencies immediately)

Effective ROI: Cost savings + faster results + specialized expertise = 300-400% better value in year 1

The Questions to Ask Yourself

Should you hire full-time or engage fractional technology leadership? Ask these questions:

1. Utilization Question

“Do we have 160+ hours per month of strategic technology work that requires CIO-level expertise?”

• If yes: Consider full-time
• If no: Fractional is more cost-effective

2. Specialization Question

“Do we need just technology strategy, or also cybersecurity, AI, and other specialized expertise?”

• If specialized needs: Fractional lets you get multiple experts for cost of one full-time hire
• If generalist needs only: Full-time might work

3. Geography Question

“Can we attract enterprise-experienced CIO talent to our location at mid-market compensation?”

• If yes: Full-time is option
• If no: Fractional gives access to talent anywhere

4. Flexibility Question

“Do our technology leadership needs vary significantly over time?”

• High variability (major projects, then steady state): Fractional offers flexibility
• Constant high demands: Full-time provides dedicated capacity

5. Stage Question

“Are we in growth/transformation mode, or steady-state operations?”

• Growth/transformation: Fractional brings experience from many transformations
• Steady-state: Full-time provides consistency

The Hybrid Path (What We Usually Recommend)

For most $50M-$150M manufacturers, the optimal model is:

Phase 1 (Months 1-12): Fractional CIO

• Assess current state
• Develop 3-year technology strategy
• Launch critical initiatives (ERP, CMMC, infrastructure modernization)
• Build/optimize IT team
• Cost: $120K-$180K

Phase 2 (Months 12-24): Fractional CIO + Internal IT Leader

• Hire strong IT Manager for operations ($120K-$160K)
• Fractional CIO reduces to 1 day/week for strategic oversight ($96K-$120K)
• Clear separation: strategy vs. operations
• Cost: $216K-$280K (less than one full-time CIO, more total capability)

Phase 3 (Year 3+): Evaluate

• If grown to $150M+: Consider transitioning to full-time CIO
• If $50M-$120M: Continue hybrid model (it’s working and cost-effective)
• Add fractional CISO or CAIO as needs evolve

The Real Question Isn’t Cost—It’s Value

Yes, a fractional CIO costs $96K-$180K vs. $275K-$390K for full-time.

But the real question is: What do you get for that investment?

Fractional CIO value proposition:

• Immediate access to enterprise-experienced leadership (no 3-6 month search)
• Focused exclusively on strategic work (not diluted with operations)
• Fresh perspective from working with multiple companies
• Flexibility to scale engagement up or down
• Access to broader network and specialized expertise
• 50-65% cost savings vs. full-time

Full-time CIO value proposition:

• Dedicated 100% to your company
• Deep institutional knowledge over time
• Always available for urgent issues
• Visible C-suite presence
• Team management and development

Both can be valuable. The question is which matches your current needs, stage, and budget.

Making the Decision

Here’s our recommendation framework:

Engage fractional CIO if:

• Revenue $20M-$120M
• Need strategic technology leadership but not full-time
• Value specialized expertise (CISO, CAIO) in addition to CIO
• Want to move quickly (no 3-6 month search)
• Prefer external perspective and broad experience

Hire full-time CIO if:

• Revenue $150M+
• Have large IT organization (10+ people)
• Constant major technology initiatives requiring full-time attention
• Can attract quality talent to your location
• Board expects full-time C-suite technology presence

Start with fractional, transition to full-time if:

• Currently $50M-$100M but growing to $150M+
• Want to “try before you buy” on technology leadership
• Need immediate help but not ready for full-time commitment
• Want fractional CIO to recruit and onboard future full-time CIO

The Bottom Line

The $200K question isn’t really about cost.

It’s about matching your technology leadership needs to your stage, budget, and strategic objectives.

For most mid-market manufacturers, the fractional model offers:

• 50-65% cost savings vs. full-time
• Faster time to value (immediate start vs. 3-6 month search)
• Access to specialized expertise
• Flexibility to scale as needs change

The manufacturers who figure this out gain years of competitive advantage while their peers are stuck debating whether they can “afford” technology leadership.

You can afford it. The question is which model delivers the most value for your specific situation.

Ready to explore your options?

Schedule a free technology leadership consultation to discuss whether fractional, full-time, or hybrid makes sense for your manufacturing business.

---

About EdgePoint Strategy: We provide fractional CIO, CISO, and CAIO services to mid-market manufacturers who need enterprise-level technology leadership without full-time costs. Our team averages 20+ years of enterprise technology experience and has guided 40+ manufacturers through technology transformation.